Tuesday, January 20, 2009
War! What is it good for...in this case Absolutely Nothing
Well event that is not true - this war in Gaza seems to me to be a total failure on all fronts. For the death of over 1300 people, the destruction of 21,000 homes and buildings and the rendering homeless of 50,000 people - what has Israel got to show for it? A weakened Israeli position and a strengthened Hamas. Nice work IDF! What a fuck up, by any measure. Here's the scorecard:
* Stopping Hamas from being able to fire rockets - Failed.
* Breaking Hamas as an organisation - Failed (though they didn't fight back as much as they boasted)
* Detering Hamas from attacking - Failed.
* Weakening Hamas politically - Failed.
* Sending a message to Hamas's sponsor, Iran - Failed.
All we have is the death, destruction and a shaky truce not that dissimilar from the one that was in place before the Gaza offensive. As wars go this has to be one of the most un-decisive ever.
Other links of note;
Israel's Next War: Today the Gaza Strip, Tomorrow Lebanon?
Robert Fisk: Posturing and laughter as victims rot.
British Jews attacked for pro-Gaza solidarity.
* Stopping Hamas from being able to fire rockets - Failed.
* Breaking Hamas as an organisation - Failed (though they didn't fight back as much as they boasted)
* Detering Hamas from attacking - Failed.
* Weakening Hamas politically - Failed.
* Sending a message to Hamas's sponsor, Iran - Failed.
All we have is the death, destruction and a shaky truce not that dissimilar from the one that was in place before the Gaza offensive. As wars go this has to be one of the most un-decisive ever.
Other links of note;
Israel's Next War: Today the Gaza Strip, Tomorrow Lebanon?
Robert Fisk: Posturing and laughter as victims rot.
British Jews attacked for pro-Gaza solidarity.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment