Thursday, November 19, 2009

The Failing List of Evidence for Global Warming Denial

A denialist website put out - with much fanfare - a list of 450 peer reviewed articles that supported their position. I guess the idea is that - how can you argue with that much evidence? Except that, like all denier flack, it consists of more spin than substance. Watch the number tumble down as people start to sceptically examine the list... A quick look at the work being done on the list shows;

- 82 papers on the list are from a non-peer revised journal, Energy & Environment.
- 7 are known to be wrong; based on flawed science.
- A known sceptic author, Roger Pielke Jr suggests that 21 papers should not be on the list (however the list author disagreed and kept them.)

Also if you look at who wrote the papers, a huge 157 of them come from 15 authors which reads like of who's who of oil industry paid denialists. Here's a sample;

S. Fred Singer 6 (Exxon mobil's money buy his opinion)
Patrick J. Michaels 26 - connected to no less than 11 think tanks and associations that have received money from oil-giant ExxonMobil
Ross McKitrick 14 - Economist linked to ExxonMobil funded groups.
Richard S. Lindzen 15 - Member of oil funded thinktank.
Willie H. Soon 13 - Linked to a whole host of oil backed front groups.
Roy W. Spencer 6 - Writer for ExxonMobil funded dirge.

Plus a whole host of other issues the whittle the list down (and eviscerate it's credibility) from a paper that criticises research methods used 20 years ago (a bit outdated now...) to papers that are complimentary to human-cased climate change. The list is bumkum. Typical denialism, big on spin, small on substance. But here is my favourite bit of the whole debark - one researcher spotted a paper that he was the lead author of on the list. He's a bit surprised as it says nothing against human-cased climate change. Here's what he says;

I just noticed I’m the lead author on one of the papers on the list. I have absolutely no idea how that paper could be construed as “skeptical of man-made global warming.” I have no idea how it could be construed as saying anything at all about man-made global warming.


And the response of the arrogant wingnut who complied the rapidly shrinking list?

That is nice that the lead author of that paper has no idea why he is on the list, maybe he should read it before commenting in the future so he does not make ridiculous comments like that.


Yup, that's right - he's telling the author of a scientific paper that he knows less about what it means than politicised interpretation of an armchair amateur climatologist.

Staggering.

2 comments:

greenfyre said...

Friendly amendment, many, manymore than 7 are known to be wrong, I just lost interest in documenting every one (my interest was to demonstrate that the list was total horseshit, not to document that every citation is wrong even though it's pretty much a given that every one is).

For anyone who cares to do the work here is a list that covers many of the list authors:
http://www.realclimate.org/wiki/index.php?title=RC_Wiki#Alphabetically_.28by_author.29

Further, note that many are also

+ not peer reviewed, and/or
+ irrelevant, and/or
+ Out of date (no longer relevant), and/or
+ not supportive of climate change Denial*

:-)

lalacordle0321 said...

av080-視訊交友.ut13077視訊聊天.台灣論壇遊戲區.台灣論壇18禁遊戲區.背包客棧論壇.成人交友.交友愛情館.昆蟲論壇.go2av視訊網.tt1069男同志論壇.購購購線上購點論壇.080aa片直播.色情論壇甜心寶貝貼片.eney伊莉論壇.gogobox 論壇.sogo 色論壇.番薯論壇av.日本av論壇.xxxpanda.34c元氣論壇.aio168論壇 .嘟嘟貼圖sex888movie影城.拓網交友-情色視訊.情色影片免費觀賞you tube影片下載.18成人網.aio交友愛情館情色自拍找援交.0951成人頻道下載.0951影片下載日本av女優.免費線上成人影片bonbonsex.mm賓館sexy diamond.dudu sex台中視訊.sexdiy免費影城.aio性愛dvd辣妹影片直播.月光論壇080大學生視訊.080美女視訊a片線上看.s383情色大網咖寶貝視訊.animal sex援交友聊天室.080性感沙灘3.本土自拍貼圖t 6成人網頁.bt成人論壇.080免費影片線上直播bt程式下載.168論壇aio色妹妹.AIO免費視訊辣妹脫衣秀.xx18 net影片交流區.85cc亞洲東洋影片視訊交友.6k聊天館.援交留言080甜心寶貝貼片區.aaaa片免費看影片.xvediox 歐美av無碼影片下載.la論壇台南援交友留言.聊天室交友.視訊情人高雄網.go2av免費影片情色 網站.一本道 a片 東京熱av免費影片.34c辣妹影片直播.小魔女自拍168論壇.discovery影片下載成人論壇.18成人avooo.youtube影片下載sex999免費影片.視訊交友ggoo.34c甜心寶貝貼片香港論壇.援交影片情色視訊交友